Florida: Canine Sniff Requires Probable Cause
Law enforcement officers are required to have probable cause to justify having a narcotics-detection dog sniff the threshold of a residence, according to the Florida Supreme Court. The Court’s ruling resolved a conflict in the state by distinguishing a dog’s sniff of luggage and packages, which are minimally intrusive, from a sniff of homes, which warrants Fourth Amendment protection. The Court concluded that a sniff test is a “substantial government intrusion” into the sanctity of the home and constitutes a “search” within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment. Moreover, it constitutes an intrusive procedure that may expose the resident to “public opprobrium, humiliation, and embarrassment.” Probable cause, not reasonable suspicion, is the proper evidentiary showing in order to make a residence dog sniff reasonable, the Court held. Jardines v State, Fla (#SC08-2101, 4-14-11); full text at http://pub.bna.com/cl/sc082101.pdf.
Current Articles
- Project Reentry: Who deserves to be fought for
- Project Reentry: A Conversation About Grief Workshop
- Safe & Just Michigan
- What your client says can deport them: Matter of Mendez Maldonado and the end of the immigration safe plea?
- Improper uses of artificial intelligence at sentencing
- SADO seeks summer interns
- SADO's Project Reentry earns the Liberty Bell Award!
- SADO is hiring an investigator!
- Project Reentry: The 100% interest rate by Lorenzo Harrell
- Obligation to pay financial penalties after a conviction is set aside
Subscriber Comments