Landmark ruling gives hope to youth sentenced to mandatory life
People v Taylor & People v Czarnecki, decided April 10, 2025
Today, Michigan joined a handful of states that recognize that young people have the capacity to change and should have the opportunity for freedom.
Andrew Czarnecki and Montario Taylor each received a mandatory sentence of life without parole for offenses that occurred when they were 19 and 20 years old. Today, the Michigan Supreme Court held that subjecting anyone under the age of 21 to mandatory life without parole violates the Michigan Constitution and constitutes cruel punishment. Read the full opinion here.
This ruling is a result of years of litigation following Miller v Alabama, where the United States Supreme Court held that children cannot be subject to the harshest penalties possible under the law. This ruling recognizes that late adolescents—those into their 20s—share many of the same characteristics as their younger counterparts.
Today’s decision is retroactive, and more than 580 Michiganders are now entitled to resentencing. The State Appellate Defender Office’s Juvenile Lifer Unit (JLU) will seek additional funding to represent as many of those people as possible in their upcoming resentencing hearings.
Current Articles
- Safe & Just Michigan
- Ask an appellate attorney: Would Alex Murdaugh have been granted a new trial if he had been an indigent defendant in Michigan?
- We are Hiring!
- What stability looks like in reentry
- Sentencing for horrific crimes short of murder
- SADO is hiring a General Clerk
- Social Media Matters
- Attempt penalties and other tricky research questions
- Safe & Just Michigan
- Project Reentry: Learning from each other
Subscriber Comments