People v Dewayne Emerson Crockran
CONFESSIONS -- Absence of Counsel
People v Dewayne Emerson Crockran
___ Mich App ___ (#294831, 04-05-11)
PC: Wilder, Saad, Donofrio
IN PRO PER
Reversed order of trial court granting motion to suppress confession and dismissing charges.
The trial court erred in suppressing defendant’s confession. The court improperly relied on Justice Cavanagh’s opinion in People v Bender, 452 Mich 594 (1996), because it is not the majority opinion. The issue is whether the police actually concealed the fact that defendant had counsel available to him and that counsel was at his disposal. The overwhelming evidence demonstrates an attorney-client relationship between defendant and his attorney existed prior to defendant’s statements to the officer. Although the attorney had not yet been paid, payment for services is but one consideration in whether an attorney-client relationship existed. There is no doubt that defendant was aware that he had counsel immediately following his arrest and that counsel was at his disposal.
Defendant asked the officer if he needed a lawyer, but never said he wanted to stop talking; defendant said that he would talk without an attorney present. According to Montejo v Louisiana, 129 S Ct 2079 (2009), the right to counsel may be validly waived in custodial interrogation after the Sixth Amendment right to counsel has attached, even if the interrogation was police initiated.
Current Articles
- Project Reentry: Who deserves to be fought for
- Project Reentry: A Conversation About Grief Workshop
- Safe & Just Michigan
- What your client says can deport them: Matter of Mendez Maldonado and the end of the immigration safe plea?
- Improper uses of artificial intelligence at sentencing
- SADO seeks summer interns
- SADO's Project Reentry earns the Liberty Bell Award!
- SADO is hiring an investigator!
- Project Reentry: The 100% interest rate by Lorenzo Harrell
- Obligation to pay financial penalties after a conviction is set aside
Subscriber Comments