Eleventh Circuit: Ex Post Facto Problem with Harsher Guidelines Sentence
The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals held that the Ex Post Facto Clause precludes a district court from sentencing a defendant under a provision of the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines that is more severe than the version in effect at the time of the offense, even though the guidelines are now merely advisory. The Court said that while the guidelines are no longer mandatory, neither are they without force. They are central to the sentencing process in that they provide a starting point that likely influences the ultimate sentence, making application of the correct guideline critically important. The Court adopted an "as applied" test, holding that the defendant must show a substantial risk that the application of the guidelines at the time of the offense resulted in the imposition of a harsher sentence. United States v Wetherald, ___F3d___ (CA 11, #09-11687, 3-28-11); full text at http://pub.bna.com/cl/0911687.pdf.
Current Articles
- Project Reentry: Who deserves to be fought for
- Project Reentry: A Conversation About Grief Workshop
- Safe & Just Michigan
- What your client says can deport them: Matter of Mendez Maldonado and the end of the immigration safe plea?
- Improper uses of artificial intelligence at sentencing
- SADO seeks summer interns
- SADO's Project Reentry earns the Liberty Bell Award!
- SADO is hiring an investigator!
- Project Reentry: The 100% interest rate by Lorenzo Harrell
- Obligation to pay financial penalties after a conviction is set aside
Subscriber Comments